Light-filled contemporary dining space with pale oak furniture and warm ivory walls overlooking a sheltered late-autumn garden.

What BayHaven Adds to Bayport's Housing Market

In September 2025, a horse-breeding farm on Stagecoach Trail was moving its last horses out. Len Pratt, president of Pratt Homes, told Finance & Commerce that once the horses were gone, "we'll be underway." He described his approach to the site's St. Croix River Valley views this way: "I'm standing out of the way, and we're letting the beauty of the site come into the houses that we're building up there."

That farm is now BayHaven. Pratt's project page describes it as more than 45 custom luxury villas, and the page includes a gallery of under-construction photos. In most suburbs, 45 homes would be a small subdivision. In Bayport, BayHaven adds more homes than the town sells in a typical year, at prices well above what those sales usually reach. It will function as a second market sitting beside the first, with its own buyer and its own price, and it is unlikely to compete much with Bayport's existing resale homes.

A town that sells about 33 homes a year

Minneapolis Area REALTORS' Local Market Update for September 2026 puts Bayport's activity in plain numbers. Over the 12 months through September 2026, the town had 36 new listings and 33 closed sales. The median sale price was $485,000, up 2.1% from the prior 12 months, and homes sold for $217 per square foot. Sellers received 99.5% of their original list price on average over that period, and homes took an average of 61 days to sell. At the end of September 2026, six homes were for sale, which is 2.0 months of supply.

Stillwater, just up the river, works at a different scale. Over the same 12 months through September 2026, it recorded 313 closed sales, about nine and a half times Bayport's count, and had 68 homes for sale at the end of September. Stillwater's 12-month median was $460,000, down 2.3%, which is below Bayport's.

The two towns' average sale prices show something their medians don't. Bayport's 12-month average was $497,993, only about $13,000 above its median. Stillwater's average was $556,774, almost $97,000 above its median. An average sits well above the median when a market has a meaningful number of high-priced sales pulling it up. Stillwater has that upper tier. In Bayport over the past year, the average and median sat close together, so no large group of high-priced sales pulled the average up.

Forty-five villas against that number

BayHaven's first phase, east of Stagecoach Trail and south of Fifth Avenue North, was planned as 35 villas and a 70-unit apartment building on a 28.11-acre site with about 12 buildable acres. Pratt described a later phase that would add another 10 villas. The Metropolitan Council authorized Bayport to put the Bayhaven 2nd Addition comprehensive plan amendment into effect on May 27, 2026, and the Council's review describes that addition as 4.43 acres for 10 single-family villas.

Forty-five homes is about a year and four months of Bayport's sales at the pace of the 12 months through September 2026. Those homes are also priced higher. In September 2025, Pratt told Finance & Commerce that prices would start in the $800,000s and that the average home would land in the "million-plus" range. Those were the builder's figures at the time. At those figures, the entry price is about 1.65 times Bayport's $485,000 median, and the expected average is roughly double it.

Pratt also said the company "does a lot of customization" and that buyers will "decide what they want, and, in essence, decide what they want to spend, too." The floor plans come in two-, three- and four-bedroom versions. The St. Clair is a three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath plan, and the Springhaven has two bedrooms and two baths. Pratt notes the plans are conceptual and subject to change. Pratt describes its villa communities as maintenance-free, with the association handling lawn care and snow removal.

A customized villa with outdoor work handled by an association and valley views in the asking price is a different product, at a different price, from the typical Bayport home sold over the past year. A household shopping for a BayHaven villa and a household shopping for a $485,000 resale home are probably not bidding against each other. BayHaven is the beginning of an upper tier that Bayport's recent sales figures have not shown, more than extra supply for its existing market.

Inspiration took about fourteen years

Bayport has absorbed a large new development before. Inspiration, on the town's west side, covers 250 acres with 252 homesites and 170 acres of restored or preserved open space. According to the Pioneer Press, the 2004 approval covered 253 single-family homes and a 75-unit senior cooperative, and by May 2015 about 80 houses had been built.

The neighborhood association's own history shows how the rest was built. D.R. Horton started building in 2012 and finished Phase II in 2013. Mattamy's 115-home Phase III was approved in 2015, and construction began in 2016. After 18 homes, Mattamy handed the remaining lots to M/I Homes in 2017, and the final roads, sidewalks and pathways were finished in 2018. From approval to finished roads took about fourteen years and several builders.

BayHaven is a smaller project with one villa builder and homes customized for each buyer. Inspiration's history doesn't predict BayHaven's timeline, but it does show what Bayport's demand has looked like. The town's demand for new homes has come in steady increments, not all at once. A villa project with a large amount of customization will likely fill in a few homes at a time, which means Bayport's resale numbers in any one season will still mostly describe resale homes.

The rental building is a separate part of the project

The 70-unit building in BayHaven's first phase is a rental community. At Home Apartments calls it The Reserve at BayHaven, at 1300 Baytown Lane, and its page lists the opening as summer 2027. It doesn't count toward Bayport's for-sale numbers. It does add households on the east side of Stagecoach Trail, a short drive from the businesses along Fifth Avenue.

The area around the project has also changed this year. In June 2026, the city finished the first phase of a walking loop on the Land & Water Legacy property just north of Lakeside Park, including a new quarter-mile trail with St. Croix views, and more improvements are planned. For a buyer comparing BayHaven with homes in the older grid near the river, that trail, the park and Fifth Avenue are the daily surroundings. Bayport's history runs through the same ground. The town grew from three settlements: Baytown around a sawmill, Bangor to the south along the lake, and Middletown to the north. Kittson's Point and Perro Creek are still landmarks from that period.

What this means if you're choosing in Bayport

BayHaven doesn't change the conditions for a buyer looking at Bayport's existing homes. With six homes for sale at the end of September 2026 and sellers getting 99.5% of original list over the past year, buyers in the town's main price range should still expect few choices and little room to negotiate. When the right house comes on the market, be ready to act. Our earlier piece on why Stillwater homes are selling faster even with more for sale shows how months-of-supply figures can mislead in small river towns, and the same caution applies here.

For a buyer considering BayHaven, the comparison is different. Bayport's 12-month median and price per square foot describe the resale homes that changed hands over the past year, so they say little about what a custom villa at the top of a new tier should cost. A better comparison is other new or recent homes with low exterior upkeep along the St. Croix, matched by floor plan, finish level and view. Ask what the builder's current price sheet says when you make the call, because the $800,000s figure dates from September 2025.

For an owner already in Bayport, the most likely effect is indirect. Some villa buyers may already live in the area and will sell a house to make the move. Each of those sales puts a home back into a resale market that had six for sale at the end of September. Over the next few years, BayHaven could add a little to Bayport's resale supply this way, without its villas competing with existing homes on price. If you own a home here and are weighing that timing, our home valuation tool can give you a starting estimate, and our Bayport neighborhood page and our guide to considering a second home in Bayport cover the town in more detail.

If you're deciding between a new villa on Stagecoach Trail and an older home a few blocks from Fifth Avenue, or deciding when to list a Bayport home as BayHaven fills in, MN Living Real Estate can compare both options for you using the town's actual sales. Let's Connect.

Work With MN Living

Whether you’re buying, selling, or launching a new development, we take a strategic and thoughtful approach tailored to your goals. With two decades of experience and a global network behind us, we’re here to ensure your real estate journey is seamless, informed, and successful.

Follow Me on Instagram